Our conclusion on Dewey’s hypothesis will be an affirmative one and, finally, a complex conception of judgment, accounting for both its social and psychological dimensions, will be suggested. More specifically, this paper will focus on Peirce’s theory of inference, scientific method, judgment and assertion. Peirce (1839-1914) and within a pragmatist framework, insofar as Dewey embraced it. Then, from a philosophical point of view, the three theses will be discussed with reference to some ideas by Charles S.

Should that be the case, then Dewey’s idea would be confirmed (at least with relation to such theses) should it not be the case, Dewey’s idea would be falsified.ĢBy “legal judgment” we shall mean the verdict deciding a legal case (including the factual and normative reasons for making it). The aim of this paper is to consider three theses applying to legal judgment and see if they can also apply to judgment in general. Le jugement doit être rigoureusement caractérisé dans son existence.ġIn 1938, in his book Logic: the Theory of Inquiry, John Dewey (1859-1952) established legal judgment as a model for the understanding of judgment in general.

Define judgment